8

I am involved in an open-source project with multiple copyright holders. The project is licensed under the 3-clause BSD license. Unfortunately, the individual code files contain no reference back to their original owners (no copyright headers), but for the project as a whole a single file LICENSE.txt, which contains the BSD license text, is provided. The project also contains a separate file which identifies all copyright holders.

However, I am struggling with a pragmatic question: the first line of the BSD license is supposed to identify the copyright owner:

Copyright (c) <year>, <copyright holder>

In our case, there is no single copyright owner (at least not for the project as a whole). So what should I put here, practically speaking? Obviously I can't just leave it out as the license itself refers to retaining "the above copyright notice". Is there a recommended way / format to list all copyright holders here, or perhaps to refer to an external list of copyright holders? We are talking 10 or more contributors by the way, some of them individuals, some companies, so it's not a short list.

I looked at how some other projects do this (e.g. Linux), but most I could find use GPL, which does not contain the <copyright owner> bit in the license - and I have sofar failed to find a project that uses BSD and has multiple owners.

9

In the United States, the US Government specifies in their publications the manner in which the copyright notice should be asserted. The copyright notice shall consist of the following three elements:

  1. The word “Copyright”; and
  2. the year of first publication of the work; and
  3. the name of the owner of copyright in the work.

Since the date of publication should be the same for all authors, I would imagine that simply repeating all of the authors after the year of first publication (separated by commas) would be perfectly adequate. That would also reinforce the idea that it is a collective work, created by multiple authors.

Full details can be found here: http://copyright.gov/title17/92chap4.pdf

Note that individual contributions to a collective work can still be copyrighted separately. See §404 of the above linked article. This is why contributors to the Mono Project are asked to assign copyright rights to Xamarin, so that there are no problems with subsequent assertion of copyright by individual contributors.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.