4

I have 2 domain objects: Project and Contract. A project can have many contracts so in the database it is modeled as a classic one-to-many relationship. Our question is this: How do you model the above in the context of microservices? Do you (a) have 2 microservices ProjectService and ContractService? or (b) Do you have one ProjectService which encompasses both Projects and Contracts?

We are thinking that answer (a) (i.e. 2 microservices ProjectService and ContractService) implies that one would have to call 2 services to retrieve and save the complete Project object hierarchy. On the other hand, answer (a) completely decouples Projects from Contracts which may be a good thing in theory, but practically useless since a Contract cannot logically exist without a Project.

What is the correct approach here? Is answer (a) an example of the nano service anti pattern?

3
  • 3
    OK, why the down vote? Is this question not useful? Does it not show research effort? What is the problem?
    – chrisl08
    Dec 1 '15 at 9:34
  • 1
    It's a great question. One I had as well. A big shame, the SE Programmers closed it. I guess they're trying to make it a weaker brother of SO... :(
    – Pepster
    Sep 11 '16 at 13:50
  • Why was it closed? This is a very practical question.
    – java_mouse
    Dec 1 '17 at 4:01
4

I've looked at the nano services anti-pattern and indeed in my opinion option (a) is an example of it.

But also, you need to consider that your domain logic here, dictates the "Project-Contracts" coupling(it's by definition) therefore the finest(smallest) granularity of the microservice should include the whole thing(Project-Contracts coupling).

Suggestion: I'd go for option (b) with the following twist, but only if you think that handling the Contracts alone requires too much code: consider having it as a private service class (not exposed to the outside world) that should only be constructed by a parameterised constructor which takes the ProjectID(or similar) as its parameter.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.