3

I'm a beginner in Java and I have a question from the "Head First Java" book. In the book, the author creates a method that takes the number as String and then convert it into int. Why do I need to take the input as a string and convert it rather than directly take it as an int. Below is he screenshot that I'm talking about.

enter image description here

9

Simply because the user's guess is most probably entered through a mechanism which only supports entering chars, or strings, but no other types. For example, System.in.read() most GUIs have a text-input control, but not a numeric input control. So, the user enters text in the control, and then the program must convert the text to a number.

  • ok. Sorry if this is a dumb question, I can still take the input directly as int correct ? – CBR Dec 6 '15 at 15:44
  • 2
    Actually, no, it is not a dumb question at all, and I am afraid that System.in.read() may have been a confusing example, because it actually returns an int instead of a char. Here is what happens: if the user types '9', System.in.read() will not return 9. It will return 57, which is the ASCII code for 9. System.in.read() should really have been declared as returning char; the char returned would have the exact same value, 57. – Mike Nakis Dec 6 '15 at 15:57
  • So, i amended my answer. – Mike Nakis Dec 6 '15 at 15:58
  • @CBR this might also be of interest to you: stackoverflow.com/a/34120618/773113 – Mike Nakis Dec 6 '15 at 18:43
  • One additionnal point: although Scanner.nextInt() could be used to read an integer as an input, internally it reads the input as a String and then convert this string to an integer (using Integer.parseInt(...)) and return it. – AilurusFulgens Sep 6 '16 at 8:32
3

To me, this example is highlighting a very important point:

Users cannot enter "Integer" values.
Nor Dates, Decimals, Floats or any other Data Type ...

... except good, old-fashioned Strings that just happen to look like values in other Data Types.

Once you accept that the user can only work in Strings and that your application works in proper Data Types, your mind will be in a very Good Place to overcome a huge number of potential run-time bugs when working with User input.

Always "format" values as you put them in front of the user and "un-format" values as you read them back. Assume that everything supplied by the User is inherently tainted and needs to be validated and verified. (e.g. is "q" numeric? How about "e"? Different languages; different tolerances).

0

It depens on the actuall method you're using. If your using System.in.read() you need to convert to int, because read() reads bytes. But if you use a Scanner you can directly read as an int like int i = new Scanner(System.in).nextInt()

0

You need to see this not from the point of view of your program code, but from the point of view of the user, who use a keyboard with about 100 keys, and who will be happily tapping on these keys. Your program then has to make sense of it.

If you tried to read just an integer, you couldn't for example distinguish between 0, +0 and -0. You couldn't distinguish between phone numbers with 0, 1 or 2 leading zeroes which are actually very, very different. You couldn't let a user enter 12cm or 12in or 12 inch. Or $12.34. Or enter dress sizes and one dress has size 12-14 instead of just a number (and no, that's not a -2, it's between size 12 and size 14

And there has been a study about severe problems with the data produced by some biologists where entering strings like 1234567e1 were interpreted as numbers instead of strings. Or someone had things called 3JAL1985, 3JAM1985 and 3JAN1985 and the first two were taken as strings and the last one as a date. So it is very important that you know how to treat any input correctly. Beyond just trying to read a number.

-3

That is the best practice, because when you read the users input as string, you can use a try...catch block to detect whether the users input qualifies to be an integer. This is done by using Integer.parseInt() method to convert the string to an integer. But when you receive the input directly as int, and in case the user enters a string of characters, your program will crash. Hope you get what I'm saying.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.