I'm using flatbuffers for the first time. I've generated my java classes and have tested out serializing / deserializaing a message. Now I'm thinking about how to integrate these in to my JavaFx and Android applications.

Is it valid to pass a DataMessage or a MessageA directly in to bussiness logic classes or my UI? It's seems really unwieldly to pass the DataMessage and then have to extract the correct payload type. So, I created wrappers around each type, so I have MessageAWrapper that contains the MessageA and Header. Should the client/UI code directly access the values from a MessageA, or is it a better practice to copy all the fields from MessageA in to new primitives defined in MessageAWrapper. Doing so seems against what Flatbuffers is for, but I also feel dirty exposign the MessageA that has flatbuffers-specific parsing methods and such. But, it's also a bit of work to have my wrapper classes copy over fields and store them, and could be error prone. But, at somewhere in my stack, I may want to, say, stuff a latitude/longitude float pair in to a convenience class called GeographicPosition. I can do this easily in a wrapper.

So I'm asking for what's the best practices for using flatbuffers / protobufs in an application wrt abstraction / separation of concerns. Most examples I see are just doing quick serialization to compare speed to JSON parsing, and I'm not seeing a full-up practical example of using it in an application to, say, stuff values in to UI controls.

For reference, I created a flatbuffers schema as follows:

table MessageA{

union MessagePayload { MessageA, MessageB, MessageC }

// top level message class. Contains a header, and a payload consisting of one of the message types specified in the MessagePayload union.
table DataMessage {
    header:Header (required);
    payload:MessagePayload (required);

root_type DataMessage;

I do this so I can examine the payload type to determine what payload I have and serialize that.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.